1. Vacuum vs. Pressure vs. Screw Conveying – How to Choose?
Conclusion:
-
Vacuum (Negative Pressure): Enclosed & clean, short-to-long distance, frequent recipe changes, prevents dust escape (fine powders/valuable powders).
-
Pressure Conveying: Long distance (>40–60 m), high throughput, centralized feeding, multi-point distribution.
-
Screw Conveyor: Short distance (<6–8 m), stable dosing, high solids content, simple design.
-
Hybrid: Vacuum feeding → small hopper → short screw dosing; or vacuum branches + pressure main line.
SEO Keywords: vacuum conveyor, pressure conveying, screw feeder, powder conveying solutions
2. How to Quickly Estimate “System Size”?
Define 3 key factors: Capacity R (kg/h), Equivalent Length Leq (m), Powder Properties.
Leq≈Horizontal length+(Vertical length×2−3)+(Elbows×1.5−3 m/each)Leq \approx \text{Horizontal length} + (\text{Vertical length} \times 2-3) + (\text{Elbows} \times 1.5-3 \, m/each)Leq≈Horizontal length+(Vertical length×2−3)+(Elbows×1.5−3m/each)
-
For conservative dilute-phase vacuum: pipe velocity v ≈ 16–20 m/s.
-
Select pipe size to avoid plugging and excessive ΔP; leave 10–20% margin.
-
For precision: supplier validates with performance curve or test run.
3. Pipe Diameter & Velocity – What’s the Range?
Dilute-phase vacuum references:
-
Fine powders: 14–20 m/s
-
Very light/floating powders: 16–22 m/s
-
Fragile particles: 8–12 m/s (use dense-phase or larger pipe, fewer bends)
⚠ Too small = high ΔP, plugging risk. Too large = low velocity, settling risk.
Start with mid-range, then refine with ΔP trend or field data.
4. Fine / Hygroscopic / Sticky Powders – How to Avoid Plugging or Blinding?
Four-in-One Strategy:
-
Filter media: PTFE/nano membrane / nano coating, + hydrophobic/oil-repellent, + anti-static for combustible dust.
-
Pre-separation: Cyclone or dropout section to reduce high-concentration peaks.
-
Dewpoint management: Insulation/dehumidification, inlet baffles for even flow.
-
Further measures: Shorten pulse interval (ΔP-triggered), check moisture/oil content, larger receivers, or staged conveying.
5. Arching Prevention & FIBC Big Bag Unloading
-
Hopper: With arch breaker, vibration, fluidizing pads, rounded corners. Sealed outlet + local dust hood.
-
FIBC: Use conductive big bags with grounding; pre-slit + docking station to prevent sudden powder surge.
-
Weighing: Shield weighing scale or level sensor from airflow (use throttling/damping or delayed sampling).
6. Is HEPA Always Needed for Vacuum Conveying?
Yes, if: indoor return air, cleanrooms, sensitive products, or zero dust leakage required.
Recommended position: Main filter → blower → HEPA → exhaust/return (HEPA as final barrier).
Verification: PAO/DOP leak test or upstream/downstream particle count; ΔP gauges for replacement timing.
7. When Do I Need Explosion-Proof / ESD Protection?
Required if combustible dust, vapors, or static discharge risks exist:
-
Conductive hoses/pipes/wheels + grounding/equipotential bonding (periodic checks).
-
Flame isolation valves/check valves + explosion venting (safe direction) or suppression.
-
Spark detection/extinguishing for grinding/cutting processes.
-
Electricals must comply with Zone 20/21/22 classification.
8. Filter Cartridges & Pulse Cleaning – Any Standard Ranges?
-
Pulse-jet cleaning pressure: 0.4–0.6 MPa
-
ΔP Management (example):
-
Initial: 600–900 Pa
-
Normal: 1000–1500 Pa
-
Alert: ≥1700 Pa → stronger cleaning/check
-
Intervention: ≥2000 Pa → stop for service/filter change
-
General rule: Always use baseline + thresholds.
9. Will Vacuum Conveying Break Fragile Particles?
Yes, if velocity is high or too many bends.
Solutions: Lower velocity (dense phase or larger pipe), minimize bends/use long-radius elbows, add deflectors/cushioning at receiver.
Verify with PSD/attrition rate during SAT acceptance.
10. Quick “Lazy Formulas”
-
Hood airflow: Q=Vf×A×60Q = V_f \times A \times 60Q=Vf×A×60
-
Equivalent length: Horizontal + vertical × 2–3 + elbows × 1.5–3 m
-
A/C ratio (Air-to-Cloth): Optimize for filter loading
-
TCO rough estimate: Energy ≈ airflow × pressure head; add filter/media/maintenance/downtime
11. Relationship Between Vacuum, Airflow & Motor Power
-
Motor HP ≠ performance.
-
Always check blower curve vs. system curve.
-
Troubleshooting:
-
Low airflow → check dampers, duct blockages, leaks, high ΔP
-
High vacuum but low flow → pipe too small, high resistance, or clogged filter
-
12. How to Write a Procurement Specification That Won’t Get Rejected?
Include:
-
Capacity: kg/h, continuous/batch, peak + margin
-
Route: sketch with H/V, elbows/tees, inter-floor, space constraints
-
Powder properties: bulk density, particle size, hygroscopic/sticky, abrasive, friable, combustible (Kst/MIE)
-
Hygiene/materials: SS304/316, CIP/SIP, quick-release
-
Safety: grounding, isolation/venting/suppression, spark detection
-
Automation: PLC/VFD, level/weight closed-loop, recipe changeover
-
Acceptance (SAT): throughput, ΔP, leakage, noise, HEPA integrity
-
After-sales: spare list, SLA, warranty
13. SAT Acceptance – What to Test?
-
Throughput: Continuous or batch meets target
-
ΔP curve: Stable, effective cleaning
-
Leakage: joints, receiver, before/after HEPA
-
Product quality: particle size, attrition, cross-contamination
-
Safety: grounding resistance, vent/isolation/suppression function, interlocks
-
Noise: day/night compliance
-
Documentation: SOPs, PM logs, electrical drawings, BOM, spares
14. Six Common Failures & Troubleshooting Sequence
-
Low airflow: damper → ΔP → duct blockage → leakage → fan belt/impeller
-
Frequent plugging: low velocity → too many bends → sticky powder → add dehumidification/insulation → pre-separator
-
ΔP spikes: sticky/wet powder → insufficient cleaning → wrong filter → inlet concentration → HEPA clogged
-
Dust leakage: gasket/quick clamp → receiver leak → HEPA damaged
-
Unstable weighing: airflow disturbance → throttling/damping hopper → delayed sampling
-
Static discharge: loose grounding → aged conductive parts → missing equipotential bonding
15. Cost Comparison – Why Cheaper May Be More Expensive Later
-
CAPEX: Main unit, ducting, controls, explosion-proof accessories, HEPA/silencer, installation
-
OPEX: Power (airflow × pressure), filters/consumables, maintenance, downtime losses
Hidden pitfalls:
-
Poor hood/duct design → high ΔP, high power cost
-
Wrong A/C ratio → high ΔP, frequent shutdowns
-
No pre-separation → short filter life
-
No ΔP baseline → reactive maintenance, frequent failures
Takeaway: Correct design + lifecycle cost = lowest total cost (TCO).
Quick Reference Tables
A. Face Velocity & Hood Airflow
-
Dumping/Weighing hood: 0.5–0.8 m/s
-
Small openings (<0.5 m²): use higher value
-
Larger openings: add baffles/side panels to cut airflow demand
Q=f×A×60Q = f \times A \times 60Q=f×A×60
B. Filter Chamber & Cleaning
-
Pulse pressure: 0.4–0.6 MPa (ΔP triggered)
-
ΔP Range (example): 600–900 Pa (initial) → 1000–1500 Pa (normal) → ≥1700 Pa (alert) → ≥2000 Pa (shutdown/maintenance)
Procurement Template (Fill-in Form)
-
Capacity: ___ kg/h (continuous/batch, peak)
-
Route: Horizontal ___ m / Vertical ___ m / Elbows ___ pcs / Floors: Y/N
-
Powder: Bulk density ___ t/m³; D50 ≈ ___ μm; hygroscopic/sticky Y/N; abrasive high/med/low; friable Y/N; combustible (Kst/MIE: ___)
-
Materials: 304/316; quick-release Y/N
-
Safety: grounding/equipotential, isolation/vent/suppression, spark detection Y/N
-
Filters: PTFE / anti-static / hydrophobic; HEPA Y/N
-
Automation: PLC/VFD, weight/level detection, auto discharge
-
Acceptance criteria: throughput, noise, HEPA integrity
-
After-sales: spares list, warranty ___ years